Hiring a Public Adjuster: Pros and Cons

Call 24/7 for a FREE Claim Assessment

Key Points:

  • Public adjusters advocate for policyholders, negotiating with insurance companies to maximize claim payouts.
  • While they can increase settlements, they charge a percentage fee, making cost a consideration.
  • Understanding when to hire a public adjuster can help homeowners and business owners make informed decisions.

Hiring a public adjuster comes with advantages and drawbacks. These professionals represent policyholders in insurance claims, ensuring fair compensation. While they bring expertise and negotiation skills, their fees and potential delays in settlements can be concerns. Below, we break down the key benefits and challenges of hiring a public adjuster to help you decide whether it’s the right move for your situation.

What Does a Public Adjuster Do?

Filing an insurance claim can be overwhelming, especially after a disaster. Public adjusters step in to:

  • Assess property damage and determine the actual cost of repairs.
  • Review insurance policies to identify coverage details and policyholder rights.
  • Negotiate settlements with insurance companies to secure a higher payout.
  • Handle claim paperwork, ensuring accuracy and compliance with policy requirements.

Unlike company adjusters, who work for insurers, public adjusters work for you, the policyholder. Their goal is to secure the highest settlement possible within the terms of your policy.

Pros of Hiring a Public Adjuster

While handling a claim yourself is possible, hiring a public adjuster can offer significant benefits. Here’s why many policyholders choose to work with one:

1. Higher Claim Settlements

Insurance companies often propose initial payouts that undervalue damages. Public adjusters have industry knowledge to:

  • Accurately assess losses, considering hidden damages insurers may overlook.
  • Present strong evidence supporting your claim to justify a higher payout.
  • Negotiate persistently, ensuring you receive fair compensation.

A study by the Florida Legislature found that policyholders who hired public adjusters received settlements 747% higher on hurricane-related claims than those who didn’t. This substantial increase demonstrates their value.

2. Reduced Stress and Hassle

Managing an insurance claim requires time and expertise. Public adjusters:

  • Handle all communications with the insurance company.
  • Manage complex documentation and prevent costly mistakes.
  • Save you time, allowing you to focus on repairs and recovery.

This is especially helpful after major losses, where navigating insurance paperwork can be overwhelming.

3. In-Depth Policy Knowledge

Insurance policies are dense and filled with legal jargon. Public adjusters:

  • Interpret policy terms, ensuring you understand your coverage.
  • Identify exclusions or loopholes that could impact your claim.
  • Advocate for your rights, preventing insurers from taking advantage of ambiguities.

This expertise helps prevent denied or underpaid claims due to misinterpretation.

4. No Upfront Costs

Most public adjusters work on a contingency fee basis, meaning:

  • You pay only if they win you a higher payout.
  • Their fee is a percentage of the final claim settlement.

This performance-based structure aligns their success with yours, ensuring they work diligently on your behalf.

public adjuster pros and cons

Cons of Hiring a Public Adjuster

While public adjusters provide valuable services, there are potential downsides to consider:

1. Fees Reduce Your Final Settlement

Public adjusters typically charge 5% to 20% of your final payout. This means:

  • The more you recover, the more they earn.
  • If damages are minor, their fee might outweigh the benefits.

For small claims, hiring a public adjuster may not be cost-effective. Always weigh potential gains against their percentage cut.

2. Possible Delays in the Claim Process

Since public adjusters conduct thorough evaluations, claim settlements may take longer. This can happen because:

  • They negotiate aggressively, leading to prolonged discussions.
  • Additional evidence gathering extends the timeline.
  • Insurance companies may push back, slowing approvals.

If you need an immediate payout, hiring an adjuster could lead to longer wait times.

3. Not All Adjusters Are Equal

Public adjusters vary in experience and reputation. Risks include:

  • Unqualified or inexperienced adjusters mismanaging your claim.
  • Unethical adjusters overpromising results and underdelivering.
  • Scam adjusters charging upfront fees without delivering services.

To avoid issues, verify their licensing, reviews, and success rates before hiring.

When Should You Hire a Public Adjuster?

Hiring a public adjuster makes sense in certain situations. Consider one if:

public adjuster pros and cons

For straightforward claims with minimal damage, a public adjuster may not be necessary. However, for substantial losses, their expertise can be invaluable.

How to Choose the Right Public Adjuster

If you decide to hire a public adjuster, consider these factors:

1. Verify Credentials

Check their state license and ensure they comply with regulations. Avoid adjusters who approach you unsolicited after a disaster.

2. Review Their Experience

Ask about their success with similar claims and request references from past clients.

3. Understand Their Fees

Get a written contract detailing their percentage and services provided. Beware of hidden charges.

4. Assess Their Communication

A good public adjuster:

  • Explains your policy and rights clearly.
  • Keeps you updated throughout the process.
  • Responds promptly to your questions.

Clear communication ensures you stay informed and confident in their work.

Maximize Your Insurance Claim with Crestview Public Adjusters

If you’re dealing with an insurance claim in New York, New Jersey, or Florida, Crestview Public Adjusters can help. Our team of licensed experts ensures you receive the maximum payout for your losses—without the stress of dealing with insurers alone. Contact us today to get the settlement you deserve.

Call 24/7 for a FREE Claim Assessment

Get More From Your Covered Insurance Claim!

Call 24/7 for a FREE Claim Assessment

Fill out the form below with details of the Claim you'd like to make.